Given the countless ways data can come out, I don't think there is a direct solution. Yes, exporting to Excel includes a lot of extra information, but deleting unneeded columns isn't that huge of a deal usually. If you are wanting a consistent set of data displayed and you're just using the list to select who you want that same data for, you can create a report that receives the person IDs only and then provides that same consistent set of data about them (name, email, cell, address, attendance this year, etc.).
Going from any list with fully customized data to a printed page that looks "normal"...not so easy. But others may have additional thoughts and tips that I would also love to hear. We have just gotten more accustomed to being paperless for most things or exporting to Excel and cleaning up.